Waggish

David Auerbach on literature, tech, film, etc.

Tag: technology (page 1 of 3)

The Bloodsport of the Hive Mind: Common Knowledge in the Age of Many-to-Many Broadcast Networks

Common knowledge is that which I know and that which I know everyone else knows. That, at least, is the easiest way to put it for my purposes here, which is how a large number of people came to believe that Donald Trump won the 2020 election—and subsequently constructed an intellectual edifice around this conviction that led to the January 6 Capitol riots.

It’s a commonplace now that we live in a fragmented age of filter bubbles in which everyone can locate a collection of online resources which will reinforce and support their views. That’s not enough, however, to get us to the point of gross norm-violating behavior. The news niches that provide reinforcing fodder to the left, right, and everywhere in between do so with an implicit antagonism toward other niches. Such conflict is their lifeblood. Readers are aware that as they embrace one point of view, there are others that, however erroneous and dangerous they may be, still coexist.

It’s only with the growth of communities of people interacting that most people gain such courage in their convictions to defy that which authoritative sources (media, political, corporate) deem to be acceptable narratives and acceptable norms. These communities generate more than validation of one’s preexisting beliefs. They generate the common knowledge that I know that many others feel the same as I do, others to whom I am joined in a community.

David Lewis gave the most well-known account of common knowledge in 1969:

Let us say that it is common knowledge in a population P that X if and only if some state of affairs A holds such that:

1. Everyone in P has reason to believe that A holds.
2. A indicates to everyone in P that everyone in P has reason to believe that A holds.
3. A indicates to everyone in P that X.

David Lewis, Convention (1969)

In other words, in an imagined group of people P, you get common knowledge of “Trump won the election” only if you have a situation in which every member of the group is not only given reason to believe that Trump won the election, but also that everyone else in the group has reason to believe (and likely the same reason to believe) that Trump won the election.

from Common knowledge, coordination, and strategic mentalizing in human social life (2019)

Gilbert Harman posed a simpler, self-referential version of self-knowledge that removes the more complex “state of affairs” variable:

Mutual knowledge might be explained as knowledge of a self-referential fact: A group of people have mutual knowledge of p if each knows p AND WE KNOW THIS, where the THIS refers to the whole fact known.

Gilbert Harman, Review of Linguistic Behavior (1977)

Historically in offline society, the second condition is the most difficult to attain. If there is consensus in the truth of some belief X in a community, that is likely a product of the ambient environment surrounding the community, attained through news, one-on-one discussions, and so on. But the knowledge that everyone else knows X is harder to glean. It can be asserted, but unless X is some fact/norm blatantly reflected in the behavioral cues of everyone one encounters (say, “You should always wear clothes in public”), the bar for X crossing into common knowledge is rather high.

Online social spaces, by their very structure and nature, lower the bar drastically by providing many-to-many broadcast channels. One rarely communicates to more than a handful of people at a time in offline, everyday life. Online, any space such as Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, a blog with comments, or a message board by default provides broadcast capabilities to every individual who contributes. To post X to an online community P on any of these networks is to communicate several things:

  1. I believe X.
  2. Everyone in P knows I believe X.
  3. Everyone in P knows everyone else in P knows I believe X.

In real life, everyday expressions of X only communicate (1) and provide a fraction of push on (2), and so no common knowledge is produced. In an online community, however, communications generate all three and provide far greater momentum toward common knowledge. Any person’s post can serve as a proxy for the unexpressed beliefs of any other person in that community. By observing how others react to someone else posting that they believe X, an observer can be implicitly validated (or rejected) within the community if they also believe X.

Many-to-many broadcasting allows, uniquely, for common knowledge to come into being far more easily in the absence of authoritative mediation and without a centralized locus of communication. Everyone in P is, by default, announcing their beliefs with a megaphone, and unlike in real life, the online community P can hear everyone’s megaphone. No one is conversing; everyone is broadcasting.

The result is discursive mob rule. For any significant belief X, momentum quickly builds up in a positive feedback loop to the point where X can reach common knowledge, and does so in the absence of any central authority. The much-vaunted moderation demanded by social network critics is not a sufficient impediment to this momentum, since moderation is very rarely invisible. If moderation removes statements of belief in X, that is tantamount to validating that many others believe that X. Moderation helps the push toward common knowledge of X along just as much as the posting of X does.

Many-to-many broadcast networks can even provide the illusion of greater unity of belief than actually exists, since not all members of a community use the megaphones. If a minority of members proclaim belief X, where X is something like “It would be a great idea to invade the Capitol building,” and there is little stated dissent, the silent votes of abstention or dissent do not get counted in the assessment of common knowledge. Where in real life there is a massive void of ignorance of what other members of one’s community think in one direction or another, in online communities the slant goes toward whoever is most aggressive with their megaphones.

Combined with the low barrier of community creation and the balkanization of online communities into self-selecting and self-reinforcing belief networks, the positive feedback becomes overwhelming, but only after many-to-many broadcasting is in play. A steady diet of clickbait and red meat can provide preoccupied partisans, but do not by themselves ensure radicalization because the concepts being promoted remain at the fairly simplistic level of soundbites. The achievement of QAnon was something beyond that which Fox News or Rush Limbaugh could ever have accomplished, because the actors playing Q only provided the barest of breadcrumbs around which the many-to-many broadcast dynamics forged a common knowledge belief system. This belief system possessed (and still possesses) a coherence, complexity, and sheer resistance to outside intrusion that could not have been possible without a far lower barrier to its constituent beliefs passing into common knowledge than was even possible until recently.

The hive mind is here, and its workings are a bloodsport.

Pathologic 2 and Ostranenie

Pathologic 2 is a tight-knit confluence of many strange ideas–about bodies and disease, about acting and theater, about community and society, about individual and state, about children and grown-ups, about utopia and transcendence, and (of course) about life and death. Separating the strands is difficult and probably useless; the resulting game is something you accept as a whole, flaws and all, or reject.

And it’s easy to reject. Responses to the game have already divided into those who appreciate the game’s sheer uncanniness but find it hostile and difficult to the point of unplayability, and those who defend those decisions to the hilt as being the very essence of the game.

This dispute isn’t resolvable. A simple description of the game is likely to put off most people, while those who are entranced by it (including myself) can only shrug when presented with its faults, because those faults are what you put up with to get something you can’t get elsewhere—assuming you want that something. I can honestly say I enjoyed it a lot more than Nier: Automata, but I can’t convince you that you will. If it’s something that will appeal to you, you’ll probably know within the next few paragraphs. If it is, I think it’s worth the effort.

Continue reading

BITWISE Q&A with David Auerbach

I’m proud to announce that today, Pantheon Books is publishing BITWISE: A LIFE IN CODE. The New York Times Book Review kindly says, ““[Auerbach] writes well about databases and servers, but what’s really distinctive about this book is his ability to dissect Joyce and Wittgenstein as easily as C++ code.” I’m grateful that the book has been so well-received.

I did a Knopf Q&A around what inspired me to write it, as well as my thoughts on technology more generally.

Continue reading

David Auerbach’s Books of the Year 2017

While the world went mad this year, I retreated a bit and did more reading than I had in some time. I have seen the pendulum of public sentiment cycle from complacency to hysteria and back twice now, and I am more fatalistic than ever about such cycles having to take their course. (My description of Thomas Pynchon’s “decoherence events” applies just as well to the Trump presidency as it does to September 11, 2001.) Being part of the collective public discourse this year was unhealthier than in any time I have ever seen.

I believe all the titles below deserve attention. The top books have been chosen based on personal significance and relevance. Appiah’s As If is a plea for a cosmopolitan pluralism (of provisional viewpoints, not of truths) based on a reading of the great Hans Vaihinger. It is a theoretical work that has far more relevance to technology than it first appears, as I try to explain in my forthcoming Bitwise: A Life in Code. Földényi’s Melancholy is a Burton-inspired chronicle that bests a thousand other intellectual histories of its kind. It spoke to me of what it is to be the sort of person who feels the need and drive to read all these books in the first place, and of the intangible benefits I gain from them. And the purportedly final version of Tom Phillips’ A Humument is a thing of beauty, drastically different from its previous editions in many regards, and one of the deepest texts of our time, fifty years after its first publication.

The greatest novel I read this year was Thomas Pynchon’s Mason & Dixon, the right novel for the right moment, but not one published in 2017.

In an attempt to provide a bit more apparent order, I have created a few subcategories for nonfiction. These are quite approximate; some books could have easily gone under a different heading. They are there to break the lists down into more manageable chunks.

When it comes to books, my eyes are bigger than my…eyes. Books under “Of Interest” are there either because (1) they are too out of my areas of knowledge for me to feel comfortable recommending them, (2) I have sufficient reservations about their content but feel they are too significant to ignore, or (3) I just haven’t read enough of them. I would feel terrible not noting Slezkine’s The House of Government, but I did not have time to read most of its 1100 pages.

Be well, read much, take care.

BOOKS OF MY YEAR

As If: Idealization and Ideals
Appiah, Kwame Anthony (Author)
Harvard University Press

Melancholy (The Margellos World Republic of Letters)
Foldenyi, Laszlo F. (Author), Wilkinson, Tim (Translator), Manguel, Alberto (Foreword)
Yale University Press


A Humument: A Treated Victorian Novel (Sixth)
Phillips, Tom (Author)
Thames & Hudson

 

LITERATURE

Into the Cyclorama
Kim, Annie (Author)
Southern Indiana Review Press


Symphony for Human Transport
Samuels, Lisa (Author)
Shearsman Books


The Golden Cockerel & Other Writings
Rulfo, Juan (Author), Weatherford, Douglas J. (Translator)
Deep Vellum Publishing


Homesick for Another World: Stories
Moshfegh, Ottessa (Author)
Penguin Press


The World Goes On
Krasznahorkai, László (Author), Szirtes, George (Translator), Mulzet, Ottilie (Translator), Batki, John (Translator)
New Directions


The Manhattan Project
Krasznahorkai, László (Author), Rotem, Ornan (Photographer), Batki, John (Translator)
Sylph Editions


So Much Blue: A Novel
Everett, Percival (Author)
Graywolf Press


Katalin Street (New York Review Books Classics)
Szabo, Magda (Author), Rix, Len (Translator)
NYRB Classics


Beasts Head for Home: A Novel (Weatherhead Books on Asia)
Abe, Kōbō (Author), Calichman, Richard (Translator)
Columbia University Press


Blackass: A Novel
Barrett, A. Igoni (Author)
Graywolf Press


The Essential Fictions
Babel, Isaac (Author), Vinokur, Val (Translator)
Northwestern University Press

Ka: Dar Oakley in the Ruin of Ymr
Crowley, John (Author), Newcomb, Melody (Illustrator)
Gallery / Saga Press

Gap Gardening: Selected Poems
Waldrop, Rosmarie (Author)
New Directions


Judgment: A Novel (Northwestern World Classics)
Bergelson, David (Author), Senderovich, Sasha (Author), Murav, Harriet (Author)
Northwestern University Press


Found Life: Poems, Stories, Comics, a Play, and an Interview (Russian Library)
Goralik, Linor (Author), Morse, Ainsley (Editor), Vassileva, Maria (Editor), Vinokour, Maya (Editor)
Columbia University Press


Remains of Life: A Novel (Modern Chinese Literature from Taiwan)
Wu He, Wu (Author), Berry, Michael (Translator)
Columbia University Press


Nest in the Bones: Stories by Antonio Benedetto
Di Benedetto, Antonio (Author), Broner, Martina (Translator)
Archipelago


Newcomers: Book One
Kovacic, Lojze (Author), Biggins, Michael (Translator)
Archipelago


Nine Continents: A Memoir In and Out of China
Guo, Xiaolu (Author)
Grove Press



Sisters of the Cross (Russian Library)
Remizov, Alexei (Author), Keys, Roger (Translator), Murphy, Brian (Translator)
Columbia University Press


Frontier
Xue, Can (Author), Gernant, Karen (Translator), Zeping, Chen (Translator), Khakpour, Porochista (Introduction)
Open Letter


The Construction of the Tower of Babel
Benet, Juan (Author), West, Adrian (Translator), West, Adrian (Introduction)
Wakefield Press


The War Nerd Iliad
Dolan, John (Adapter)
Feral House


Drilling through Hard Boards: 133 Political Stories (The German List)
Kluge, Alexander (Author), Hoban, Wieland (Translator)
Seagull Books


Earthly Signs: Moscow Diaries, 1917-1922 (New York Review Books Classics)
Tsvetaeva, Marina (Author), Gambrell, Jamey (Translator)
NYRB Classics


Balcony in the Forest (New York Review Book)
Gracq, Julien (Author), Howard, Richard (Translator), Howard, Richard (Foreword)
NYRB Classics


Go, Went, Gone
Erpenbeck, Jenny (Author), Bernofsky, Susan (Translator)
New Directions



The Collected Poems of Li He (Calligrams)
He, Li (Author), Frodsham, J.D. (Translator), Rouzer, Paul (Preface)
New York Review Books


Chinese Poetic Writing (Calligrams)
Cheng, Francois (Author), Riggs, Donald (Translator), Seaton, Jerome (Translator)
New York Review Books


The Complete Old English Poems (The Middle Ages Series)
Williamson, Craig (Translator), Shippey, Tom (Introduction)
University of Pennsylvania Press


The Book of Disquiet: The Complete Edition
Pessoa, Fernando (Author), Pizarro, Jerónimo (Editor), Costa, Margaret Jull (Translator)
New Directions

 

HUMANITIES

Melancholic Habits: Burton's Anatomy & the Mind Sciences
Radden, Jennifer (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Warburg Years (1919-1933): Essays on Language, Art, Myth, and Technology
Cassirer, Ernst (Author), Lofts, S. G. (Translator)
Yale University Press


Dystopia: A Natural History
Claeys, Gregory (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Rift in The Lute: Attuning Poetry and Philosophy
de Gaynesford, Maximilian (Author)
Oxford University Press


David Jones
Dilworth, T (Author)
Jonathan Cape

The Messages We Send: Social Signals and Storytelling
Ferrari, G. R. F. (Author)
Oxford University Press

The Mind of the Book: Pictorial Title-Pages
Fowler, Alastair (Author)
Oxford University Press

The Natural and the Human: Science and the Shaping of Modernity, 1739-1841
Gaukroger, Stephen (Author)
Oxford University Press


Changing the Subject: Philosophy from Socrates to Adorno
Geuss, Raymond (Author)
Harvard University Press



Res Publica and the Roman Republic: 'Without Body or Form'
Hodgson, Louise (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Epic Distilled: Studies in the Composition of the Aeneid
Horsfall, Nicholas (Author)
Oxford University Press

I, Me, Mine: Back to Kant, and Back Again
Longuenesse, Béatrice (Author)
Oxford University Press


Art and Myth of the Ancient Maya
Chinchilla Mazariegos, Oswaldo (Author)
Yale University Press

Wilfrid Sellars and the Foundations of Normativity
Olen, Peter (Author)
Palgrave Macmillan

The Subject of Experience
Strawson, Galen (Author)
OUP Oxford


The Emotions in Early Chinese Philosophy (Emotions of the Past)
Virág, Curie (Author)
Oxford University Press

Hercules Segers: Painter, Etcher, A Catalogue Raisonn
Segers, Hercules (Artist)
nai010 publishers/Rijksmuseum

 

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY

Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst
Sapolsky, Robert M. (Author)
Penguin Books



After Digital: Computation as Done by Brains and Machines
Anderson, James A. (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Lazy Universe: An Introduction to the Principle of Least Action
Coopersmith, Jennifer (Author)
Oxford University Press



 

THE SOCIAL SCIENCES

Prisoners of Reason
Amadae, S. M. (Author)
Cambridge University Press





The Sum of Small Things: A Theory of the Aspirational Class
Currid-Halkett, Elizabeth (Author)
Princeton University Press


Marx's Inferno: The Political Theory of Capital
Roberts, William Clare (Author)
Princeton University Press


A Brief History of Economic Thought
Roncaglia, Alessandro (Author)
Cambridge University Press


Paths to Fulfillment: Women's Search for Meaning and Identity
Josselson, Ruthellen (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Timeliness of George Herbert Mead
Joas, Hans (Editor), Huebner, Daniel R. (Editor)
University of Chicago Press


The Enigma of Reason
Mercier, Hugo (Author), Sperber, Dan (Author)
Harvard University Press


Shame: A Brief History (History of Emotions)
Stearns, Peter N. (Author)
University of Illinois Press


The Truth about Language: What It Is and Where It Came From
Corballis, Michael C. (Author)
University of Chicago Press


 

HISTORY AND POLITICS


Cuz: The Life and Times of Michael A.
Danielle S. Allen (Author)
Liveright


The Water Kingdom
Ball, Philip (Author)
Vintage


False Dawn: Protest, Democracy, and Violence in the New Middle East
Cook, Steven A. (Author)
Oxford University Press


Inside Private Prisons: An American Dilemma in the Age of Mass Incarceration
Eisen, Lauren-Brooke (Author)
Columbia University Press


The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America
Fitzgerald, Frances (Author)
Simon & Schuster


The Causes of War and the Spread of Peace: But Will War Rebound?
Gat, Azar (Author)
Oxford University Press


A History of Judaism
Goodman, Martin (Author)
Penguin Press


The Killing Wind: A Chinese County's Descent into Madness during the Cultural Revolution
Hecheng, Tan (Author), Mosher, Stacy (Translator), Jian, Guo (Translator)
Oxford University Press


One Long Night: A Global History of Concentration Camps
Pitzer, Andrea (Author)
Little, Brown and Company


The Habsburg Empire: A New History
Judson, Pieter M. (Author)
Harvard University Press


The Transformation of American Liberalism
Klosko, George (Author)
Oxford University Press


Politics in the Roman Republic (Key Themes in Ancient History)
Mouritsen, Henrik (Author)
Cambridge University Press



Sold People: Traffickers and Family Life in North China
Ransmeier, Johanna S. (Author)
Harvard University Press




Classical Greek Oligarchy: A Political History
Simonton, Matthew (Author)
Princeton University Press



The Cold War: A World History
Westad, Odd Arne (Author)
Basic Books

 

COMICS

Poppies of Iraq
Findakly, Brigitte (Author), Trondheim, Lewis (Author), Dascher, Helge (Translator)
Drawn and Quarterly


Satania
Vehlmann, Fabien (Author), Kerascoet (Illustrator)
NBM Publishing


It Don't Come Easy
Dupuy, Philippe (Author), Berberian, Charles (Author), Dascher, Helge (Translator)
Drawn and Quarterly


The Green Hand and Other Stories
Claveloux, Nicole (Author), Smith, Donald Nicholson (Translator), Clowes, Daniel (Introduction)
New York Review Comics


Voices in the Dark
Lust, Ulli (Author), Brownjohn, John (Translator), Knight, Nika (Translator), Beyer, Marcel (Draft Writer)
New York Review Comics


My Favorite Thing Is Monsters
Ferris, Emil (Author), Ferris, Emil (Artist)
Fantagraphics Books

Pascin
Sfar, Joann (Author), Gauvin, Edward (Translator)
Uncivilized Books


Beanworld Volume 4: Hoka Hoka Burb'l Burb'l
Marder, Larry (Author), Marder, Larry (Illustrator)
Dark Horse Books


The Interview
Richards, Jaime (Translator), Manuele Fior (Author)
Fantagraphics Books


Yvain: The Knight of the Lion
Anderson, M.T. (Author), Offermann, Andrea (Illustrator)
Candlewick


Demon (4 Book Series)
Shiga, Jason (Author), Shiga, Jason (Illustrator)



The Customer is Always Wrong
Pond, Mimi (Author)
Drawn and Quarterly


The Best We Could Do: An Illustrated Memoir
Bui, Thi (Author)
Harry N. Abrams

 

OF INTEREST





How the Mind Comes into Being
Butz, Martin V. (Author), Kutter, Esther F. (Contributor)
Oxford University Press




Herder's Hermeneutics: History, Poetry, Enlightenment
Gjesdal, Kristin (Author)
Cambridge University Press





Capitalism without Capital: The Rise of the Intangible Economy
Haskel, Jonathan (Author), Westlake, Stian (Author)
Princeton University Press


The Quantum Revolution in Philosophy
Healey, Richard (Author)
Oxford University Press


Stalin: Waiting for Hitler, 1929-1941
Kotkin, Stephen (Author)
Penguin Press


Pompey, Cato, and the Governance of the Roman Empire
Morrell, Kit (Author)
Oxford University Press


The Allure of Battle: A History of How Wars Have Been Won and Lost
Nolan, Cathal J. (Author)
Oxford University Press


A History of Law in Europe: From the Early Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century
Padoa-Schioppa, Antonio (Author), Fitzgerald, Caterina (Translator)
Cambridge University Press


The Cambridge History of Communism: Volume 1, World Revolution and Socialism in One Country 1917–1941
Pons, Silvio (Editor), Smith, Stephen A. (Editor)
Cambridge University Press



The House of Government: A Saga of the Russian Revolution
Slezkine, Yuri (Author)
Princeton University Press




No Future: Punk, Politics and British Youth Culture, 1976–1984
Worley, Matthew (Author)
Cambridge University Press


The Expanding Blaze: How the American Revolution Ignited the World, 1775-1848
Israel, Jonathan (Author)
Princeton University Press


The Sorcerer's Apprentice: An Anthology of Magical Tales
Zipes, Jack (Editor), Frank, Natalie (Illustrator)
Princeton University Press

The Binding of Isaac and the Binding of Symbols

In The Stupidity of Computers, I discussed how computers require rigidly defined ontologies, which are then enforced on us. What happens in the collision between slippery life and a fixed ontology? Here is a case study. Here the fixed ontology is that of video games, and the “life” is the Christian religion.

The Binding of Isaac is an indie game by Edmund McMillen (art and design) and Florian Himsl (programming) about a boy, Isaac, with an insane fundamentalist Christian mother. When she hears the voice of God telling her to kill Isaac (as seen in the opening cutscene), Isaac flees into the basement and fights the terrible creatures therein, going deeper and deeper into the basement until confronting Mom herself (and, later in the game, Satan). You, as Isaac, shoot tears at the enemies to kill them. The enemies, which include all manner of biological horrors (fistulae, fetuses, pinworms, blastocysts, and lots of bugs), all try to kill you.

Bosses include Mom, Satan, Pin, Chub, Fistula, Blastocyst, the Blighted Ovum, Scolex, Loki, the Seven Deadly Sins, and the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse (image c/o Binding of Isaac Wiki)

The game itself is firmly neo-classicist. It is a top-down 2D action game that will look familiar to people who played Legend of Zelda. The basic mechanics are the same: you control a character moving from room to room in a maze and killing enemies. There are multiple levels, with difficult bosses at the end of each level.  You pick up power-up items that increase your character’s skills in one way or another: speed, damage, health, etc. (Some items hurt you, some are a mixed bag.)

The game is extraordinarily difficult, requiring way more coordination and reflexes than I possess, and it is unforgiving: death sets you back to the beginning every time. But for the dextrous it is prodigious, and because of the randomly generated levels and a plethora of unlockable items, secrets, and endings, the game has picked up a well-deserved diehard following. While traditional, the game is far more elaborate and skillful than the norm–McMillen clearly has spent a great deal of time thinking about gameplay construction and balance. (McMillen did the similarly neo-classical Super Meat Boy, a punishing platformer requiring utterly precise split-second timing.)

But the story and the symbols are what concern me, and specifically the mapping of the game’s symbols to the game’s functional roles.

Courtesy of the Binding of Isaac Wiki, which has an exhaustive list of items, enemies, and everything else in the game, consider a few game items (that is to say, symbols) and their functional roles in the game :

ItemEffectInfo
Wire Coat Hanger

Wire Coat Hanger.png

Increases Tears by 2.

Found in the Boss Room.

Isaac gets a coat hanger through his head.
Wire Coat Hanger Isaac.jpg
Stem Cells

Stem Cells.png

+1 heart container. It also heals a half heart.Isaac Stem Cells.png

A fetus grows on the side of Isaac’s face.

Wooden Spoon

Wooden Spoon hq.png

Increases speed by 2.

Found in the Boss Room.

Spoon Isaac.jpg

Isaac has beat marks from a spoon.

These power-up items have perfectly traditional functions, making Isaac faster, giving him more health points, or increasing his tear firepower. What’s left for the player to infer is why the items have the functional effects they do. This knowledge is irrelevant to the game’s function but contributes to the underlying “story.” So the Wooden Spoon, as well as another item, the Belt, increase speed because Isaac was beaten and he runs from them. Stem cells are both anti-Christian and associated with health. The Wire Coat Hanger, a reminder of abortion, would make a good Christian boy cry.

(Sometime the notable inferences are not between symbol and functional role but between name and image. Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert all increase health, but the item images are of dog food and spoiled milk.)

But some links are left vague or underdetermined. Why does the Wire Coat Hanger go through Isaac’s head after you pick it up? Maybe just for gross-out purposes, or maybe because Isaac’s mother wanted to abort him? Very little exposition is explicitly given in the brief story cut-scenes, leaving ambiguous the extent to which all these horrible things actually happened to Isaac.

Also, the symbolism does not seem to be especially organized: Judeo-Christianity is the dominant note, but bits and pieces appear from other mythologies such as an ankh, a tarot deck, Polyphemus, the Necronomicon, and many references to other games. In addition to Isaac, you can play as Judas, Cain, Eve, Magdalene, or Samson. (References to Jesus in the game, however, are exceedingly rare.) These characters are ultimately just Isaac’s alter ego, with Eve and Magdalene contributing to a strong implication that Isaac likes to cross-dress.

So the mappings from symbol to functional role are fairly piecemeal, constructed with an eye toward gameplay rather than a perfectly coherent story per se. For example, Isaac is able to use “holy” and “Satanic” items alike and in combination with little incident:

ItemEffectInfo
The Bible

The Bible.png

Transforms the player into an angel, allowing him or her to fly over obstacles for the current room only.

Isaac Fate.png

Instantly kills Mom, Mom’s Heart, and It Lives.

Satan or Isaac will instantly kill you for using it, even after death (unless you have The Wafer).

The Book Of Belial

Bookofbelial.png

Doubles damage until you exit the room, just like The Devil tarot card. It also gives Isaac an angry face with empty eye sockets with blood running down his face until he exits the room.

Belialisaac.jpg

Unlocked by beating the full game. Can rarely be found in secret rooms and the devil room. Judas starts the game with this item.
Rosary

Rosary.png

Increases Faith by adding 3 Soul Hearts and increases the chance for a Bible to appear in the subsequent levels of the playthrough.

Found in Item Room and Shop.

Rosary Isaac.jpg

Isaac has a cross amulet.

The Pact

Thepact.png

Increases Damage by 1 and rate of fire by 2. The player also gains 2 soul hearts.

If you have Transcendence when you pick up The Pact, you will have a body again, but with demon wings like the Lord of the Pit item grants.

Available by defeating ‘The Fallen‘ or traded in a Devil Room.

The Pact Isaac.jpg

Turns the player’s body black, gives him small horns, and makes him seem more aggressive.

While using the Bible on Satan (or the final final boss, who is Isaac him/yourself) will kill you, this is more the exception than the rule. I’m not sure to what extent it was intended that possessing the Wafer prevents you from dying if you use the Bible to fight Satan, or even what the symbolic import of it is. There are so many items that the interactions between them (such as Transcendence and The Pact, another baffling combination) were probably determined ad hoc, especially as many items were added in several updates after the game’s initial release.

I don’t mean to say that the symbolism is a meaningless mishmash. The story and content are deeply significant to McMillen: in an interview he discussed his oppressive born-again upbringing, as well as the disappointment he felt upon realizing that the entire world of the Bible was not real. The links between games and religion are very real to him: “I think Catholicism is quite interesting. It’s very close to D&D.”

But I’m not sure that aside from memorably grotesque dark humor, the specific symbol set has contributed that much to the game’s popularity. When you are dodging 15 enemies while shooting explosive projectiles at them, it doesn’t matter whether the enemies are spaceships or aborted fetuses, or whether the projectiles are missiles or your own vomit/tears/urine.

ItemEffectInfo
Number One

Shape3061.png

Sets the player’s tears to their maximum rate of fire and minimum range.

Combining Number One with Technology causes the fire rate to increase significantly and turns the beam yellow.

Bug: Collecting The Mark (and maybe other tear-changing items) before collecting Number One increases your rate of fire to max, but doesn’t decrease your range.

Number one!.jpg

Isaac stops crying and smiles while yellow colored projectiles (urine) come from his lower body rather than his face.

YellowTears.jpg

Ipecac

IPECAC1.png

Green projectiles fired from the mouth causing poison/explosive damage. Shots are fired in an arc, so they will fly over enemies unless extremely close (close enough to take damage from the explosion).Isaac Ipecac.png

Isaac gets very sick and he spits his projectiles.

The symbolism is not irrelevant to the gameplay, however. Seemingly incidental details make a difference to how various pieces of the game interact functionally. For example: Cain only has one eye, so if you play as Cain and he picks up the weapon Technology (an eye laser), he can no longer shoot tears out of his other eye. The other characters still can. Here the symbol dictated part of the functional role.

But the symbolism only inconsistently has such functional impact. One can make deals with the Devil himself (before fighting him later in the game), and while you won’t be able to purchase holy items from him, items like Guppy’s Head and A Quarter lack a certain Satanic elan possessed by other Deal with the Devil items like the Pact, Lord of the Pit, and Whore of Babylon.

ItemEffectInfo
Guppy’s Head

Guppyshead 1.png

Spawns 2-4 Blue Flies to damage enemies. Flies won’t spawn if entering a door while using it.Found in Devil Room for 2 hearts, Red Chests, Challenge Room or as a drop from fight with The Fallen.

If you collect any three of the Guppy’s items (Guppy’s Head, Guppy’s Tail, Guppy’s Paw, Dead Cat), Isaac will becomes Guppy. If it’s Guppy’s Paw or Guppy’s Head, you only need to use it once (you can drop it afterward) to make the game counts you as “carrying” the item.

Whore of Babylon

Whore-of-babylon.png

If you have half a heart, a message reading “What a horrible night to have a curse…” appears on the screen and the player becomes the Whore of Babylon. This increases their damage by 3 and speed by 2 and they will stay in that form until leaving a room with more than half a heart.Eve starts the game with this item.

Found in the Devil Room, Item Room or after defeating The Fallen. Might appear in the shop for 2 hearts or 15 coins as well.

When activated while the player has Fate, the Holy Grail, or the Bible activated, the wings turn black.

Whore of Babylon Isaac.jpg

Isaac becomes a spawn of Satan.

The Mark

The mark.png

Increases Damage by 2 and adds one soul heart.

Will kill you if you have 2 or less hearts when you make the devil deal despite giving you one soul heart.

Available by defeating The Fallen or traded in a Devil Room.

The Mark Isaac.jpg

Isaac sports three 6’s in a circular pattern.

We are very close, then, to a world of allegory, except that in relation to Christian allegory, the terms have been reversed. Instead of mapping a world of secular symbols onto a common and uniform religious conceptual scheme, religious symbols are mapped, somewhat haphazardly, onto the firmly fixed conceptual vocabulary of a video game.

Allegory is only possible (and popular) within a community in which there is a shared conceptual vocabulary to allegorize. Religion is ideal for this purpose, providing such an overarching unity of conceptual arrangement that most members of that religious community stand a good chance of decoding the allegory. Mapping the plot and symbols of William Langland’s medieval allegory Piers Plowman onto Christian concepts may not be blatantly obvious, but it is a process firmly enmeshed in the dominant religious conceptual arrangement of the period.

In the absence of a complex religious vocabulary, certain cultural universals like beauty, sex, and death are also manageable for allegorical purposes, but anything more specific, such as politics, poses a problem. If the reader does not feel the allegorical basis of the story, the allegory may just appear empty and contrived, or even incomprehensible.

In a restricted conceptual vocabulary, such as that of a top down 2D game, the problem of a lack of shared vocabulary disappears. Every player knows the conceptual vocabulary of health, shots, power ups, enemies, and bosses. Their significance within the game is indisputable: they amount to how you play and win the game. They form the ontology of a video game.

As for decoding the allegory, the symbolic mapping is made explicit, even if the meaning of the mapping is not. The Belt and the Wooden Spoon increase Isaac’s speed, but one must then infer that they do so because Isaac has been beaten with them. Having the Whore of Babylon item gives you far more firepower, but only if you’re very low on health. And so players begin to use a Judeo-Christian symbology in a very particular and peculiar way because The Binding of Isaac makes use of them in a rigidly allegorical context.

McMillen clearly feels this allegory quite deeply. But what about players, to whom these symbols may have much less powerful associations? The game must have an influence, however small, on how players will think of those symbols. The computer doesn’t care whether the damaging projectiles are bullets, tears, or urine, but because these terms are used in other contexts, their binding to the conceptual realm of the video game has some impact.

This impact was not calculated, nor is it easily grasped. The symbology is based on the Judeo-Christian mythos while not being beholden to it. The Binding of Isaac is striking because it is such an extreme case and uses a symbology that has rarely (if ever) been put to such use in a video game before. But in participating in a mapping from symbols to an ontology, we participate in the mutation of the meaning of those symbols. The individual functional roles of video games bleed into the symbols they use and stay with us every time we see a wafer, a fistula, or a Bible thereafter.

« Older posts

© 2021 Waggish

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑